I know that everybody and their mother knows about MUA's bargain eye palettes and I know it seems like I'm a little late to join the party but, it was really hard for me to get hold of this particular palette, they never had it in my nearest Superdrug for some reason so I haven't had it as long. When I first saw this palette I was so excited to try it because I have some of MUA's other palettes and for the price they are, they're pretty good. I've had this particular one for a good few months (can't remember exactly how many) and I've tried it out a few times and it's terrible! My disappointment was much too large to include it in my Disappointing Products post (which you can find here) and I felt it needed it's own post for me to fully explain why I hate this palette so much.
I love the fact that MUA started to put these Mini Master Class's on the back of their palettes because I think it's a nice way to try out some of the colours and see what they're like. Now I first looked at the colours it said to use and thought "well I definitely won't be wearing this everyday" because in the pan they look so bright, but when I tried it out they have very little colour pay off. In fact, they kind of just look like big clumps of glitter on the lids - not a pretty look!
As you can see, the first colour on each row is incredibly light and probably meant to highlight. The other colours all do look pretty pigmented on the back of my hand but that's after picking up a hell of a lot of product on my fingers. When you use a brush on the eyes, the colour pay off is no where near as good and you have to really build up the colour. Even after adding an unnecessary amount of shadow to your eyes, it still doesn't look the same colour as it does on the back of my hand. Which was what most disappointed me because I absolutely loved shade 2 (second in on the left, top row), shade 9 (second in on the right, bottom row) and shade 10 (last one on the right, bottom row) when they're swatched on the back of my hand. Unfortunately, this makes it really hard to create any eye looks that actually look good (trust me, I've tried).
Another thing I really hate about this palette is how chalky the powders are. All my other MUA palettes have quite a nice consistency and so I was surprised by how chalky and messy these are. They go all over the pan and can sometimes fall all over your cheeks whilst applying (not a big deal as I've started doing my eyes first for this reason but it is pretty irritating). I think this texture also makes them look pretty horrible on the lid and doesn't help to stop the clumpy glitter look they have.
Honestly, I have no idea about lasting power of these eyeshadows because I've never worn one long enough to find out. Considering the little colour pay of you get in the first place and the odd texture I wouldn't expect them to last a long time even with a primer.
Overall, I'm incredibly disappointed with this palette. I was so excited because the colours looked gorgeous and I had such high expectations and it was just a complete dud. I'd give this palette 1/5 stars because although I absolutely hate it, I will probably get some wear out of the lighter highlight colours.
I'd just like to say that the other MUA 12 eyeshadow palettes aren't like this at all. They all have pretty decent pigmentation and they're pretty smooth to apply - not chalky at all. It's just this palette that the quality isn't there.
I hope you have a fabulous day,
Nikki x